Designing a Strawberry Bed Utilizing Thermoelectric Cooling with Temperature Monitoring
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The main learning achievement is to develop and design of the strawberry bed using thermoelectric cooling device helping farmers not only in cold temperature province area but also in humid weather area in the Philippines. It encourages other fruit vendors to have this kind of project in their own backyard for income generating purposes and will make the price of the strawberry lower and more fresher than having delivered strawberry from other places. I would recommend to add a cooling water tank to spray automatically the strawberry plant to help maintain the desired controlled temperature of 16 degree temperature.
委員2
1. The students were able to design a prototype that will utilize thermoelectric cooling device that can maintain suitable temperature for growing a strawberry.
2. This project will help the strawberry farmers in growing their crop and help increase their harvest.
控制草莓生長環境是很好的構想。
如果考慮濕度控制在65到80間是否能夠讓草莓生長的更好？可考慮加入濕度控制。
只利用5顆草莓鑑定好壞不符統計要求。
Controlling the environment in which strawberries grow is a good idea.
If you consider whether controlling the humidity between 65 and 80 can make strawberries grow better? Consider adding humidity control.
Only using 5 strawberries to identify good or bad does not meet the statistical requirements.
委員5
Thermoelectric cooling has been around as new technology for cooling systems. The presentation does not show any innovation and showed only an experiment for strawberries thriving in a controlled environment that uses thermoelectric cooling. Perhaps, the group can explore the recommendations presented in the paper and create an equipment specific for strawberries that can also be energy saving.
The University established a community service learning program for increase social awareness and concern to the needs and problems of the community which was participated by the members of the faculty, the support personnel and the students. The program literally do not only relate to the classroom learning but to the realities of life. It is committed to help students become ethical, responsible and engaged members of even wider communities and to develop a sense of commitment to purposes larger than themselves. The program exposes students to significant social issues and empowers them to solve problems and effect positive change. A support group/participating team composed of highly motivated and competent volunteers. The group promotes Environmental Protection and Conservation, Livelihood, Education, Tamaraw Counting and lastly Outreached Socio-civic Community Services and increases the interaction among faculty, staff and students. The volunteer- students work with several community service programs that help promote positive community involvement and strong university-to-community relationships. Participants expand their knowledge and broaden their sphere of influence to the communities they touch. The volunteer grows from his or her experience to become more aware of societal issues and reaps the benefits of helping others.
委員2
She explained comprehensively how it can help to SDG.
委員3
The advantages: conservation for endanger species. show the passion for endanger species. They did the filed experiment.
The disadvantages: the methodology should write down in more details. They can improve their methodology.
This program fully supports the achievement of SDGs. It embodies wildlife preservation and provide support to the indigenous community. To continuously support this program, more funding can be sourced and close collaboration with the government for stringent policies to maintain safety and security in the area.
1. The major accomplishment of this Zeepsip is that within the short span of time, the proponents were able to formulate a product that can serve as a perfect alternative to environmentally-harmful plastics. Looking for eco-friendly alternatives to plastic straws is no easy feat because of the multitude of other options available. However, ZeepSip has been able to tap into the weaknesses of those alternatives, which in turn became the product's major strength, the durability and ease of use.
2. What can be improved is for the proponents to expound the production process of the biodegradble straw "Zeepsip" since it is not well defined in the presentation. With the proper explanation of each process that includes the materials and equipment, the proposal can be better and clearer to readers/angel investors who are interested to know more about the product.
3. Finally, this is a great innovation link to various sustainable deveopment goals.
委員2
ZeepSip is an environment-friendly product that is easy to use like a regular straw. This organic and biodegradable straw was innovated in an effort to reduce at least 1% of straw waste in the Philippines for the next 25 years. In addition, the production of the straw will be helpful to the community of farmers and persons with disabilities in terms of livelihood. The production of ZeepSip is linked to SDGs 2, 11, 12, and 15.
While the creation of the product supports the achievement of several SDGs, the use of rice hulls (husks) for drinking straw is no longer an innovation because this product is already on the market. However, the intention to help farmers earn more income and establish partnerships with food companies is commendable. I suggest that to explore for additional biodegradable waste material that can be combined with rice hulls to improve the product as an incremental innovation.
AGriAngatPinas (AGAP): An Online Agriculture System Application for Rice Crop Production with Record Management and Mobile Data Visualization
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
This research is very helpful for rice farmers. It can also be further developed to cater other vegetable farming.
委員2
The system will be very beneficial in the field of farming.
委員3
The online agricultural system is developed specifically for one company. Although it aims to develop sustainable plantation, it is not clear how this can support in achieving the SDGs at a large scale. Not only is the system specific to one company but to one location as well. Suggesting that the group review how this can be used on a large scale.
委員4
如果能夠繼續將建議事項研究人員所推薦內容完成，則本計畫將非常成功且完整。
The program will be a very successful and complete program if it continues to complete what the Suggestion Researchers recommend.
Non Destructive Microcontroller-Based Carabao Mango Ripeness Grader
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
Improvement of data. since image processing is involved However, the study is very beneficial to the farmer
委員2
1. The group was able to design a prototype that will grade the ripeness of the carabao mango. They were able to show the three categories of the ripeness: ripe, unripe and partially ripe.
2. This is a good project that will help our mango farmers determine the ripeness of their harvest.
目前採用的兩項檢測感測器，做出來的結果相當的不錯。最好增加自動化輸送系統，以達到自動分級的目的。若能完成建議所列的項目，則此系統就能達到真正的使用價值。
The results of the two detection sensors currently used are quite good. It is better to add an automatic conveying system to achieve the purpose of automatic grading. If the items listed in the suggestions can be completed, the system can achieve real use value.
委員5
Sorting and grading fruits is truly a time-consuming and tedious process. Integrating the available technology into the entire agricultural distribution process would probably resolve some of the quality control issues specifically for mango exporters. The non-destructive process that it promises would definitely be an innovative feature that would not only lessen human intervention in the entire quality control measure but would assure that the items would be screened properly using artificial intelligence.
The product is innovative and a sustainable form of cultivation. Due to the rising cost of agricultural products, there is motivation to grow your own vegetables at home without worrying about pots, soil, and weather conditions. Those who live in apartments and condominiums may find Hydropods very convenient and useful for vertical gardens. Dumangan hydroponics support sustainable agriculture because it saves water, land, and land resources. It contributes to the reduction of greenhouse gases and help in soil and energy conservation. I suggest further prototyping and testing to ensure that this is the best and most efficient sustainable design.
委員2
The project has a 5-year plan that aims to achieve 5 major objectives linked to SDGs 13, 11, and 8. The innovative product is a new home appliance that will reduce single plastic usage, reduce travel to market, and provide incentive for urban farming. A product that aims to heavily invest in urban farming and provide necessary training to farmers to pivot to urban farming in cooperation with the government. This is, so far, the most innovative product produced.
委員3
This work is tight to SDGs. The presentation is great in art design and data analysis. Although this idea has been well-know for world-wide, but the new design may be useful for urban people healing small things. How about changing the plastic material into biodegradable material?
IoT-Based Monitoring and Regulating device for Backyard Oyster Mushroom Farms
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The paper focuses on the innovation of how Oyster Mushroom farmers improve their craft with less physical monitoring, the project enables the Oyster Mushroom farmers to monitor the whole cycle of Oyster Mushroom Farming and implement the necessary adjustments to the key parameters that will allow the mushrooms to grow in its fullness. it uses a microcontroller that acts as the central monitoring mechanism that sends a notification to the farmers about the status of the farm allowing the farmer to act accordingly if adjustments are necessary and allowing the adjustments to be implemented via the Internet.
委員2
1. The students were able to design a device that will ensure the monitoring and maintenance of optimal conditions of oyster mushrooms. They were able to control 4 parameters, namely: pH levels along with the substrate’s moisture while composting, and the humidity together with the temperature ambiance of the farmhouse.
2. This project will help the farmers in their harvest and will be able to provide a smooth continuous flow in their production.
研究開發真正能夠提供菇農監控栽培蘑菇的生長環境，考慮監控的項目完整，利用微處理機完成工作，自動化減輕農民的工作負擔，是一個很好的成果。
Research and development can really provide mushroom growers with monitoring the growth environment of cultivated mushrooms, considering the integrity of the monitoring items, using microprocessors to complete the work, and automating to reduce the work burden of farmers is a very good result.
Mobile Based: Banana Leaf (Musa Acuminata Balbisiana) Disease Detection using Image Segmentation
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The team excellently and effectively utilized the algorithms used in detecting common banana leaf diseases.
The presentation is smoothly delivered and the content is informative.
委員2
Additional method can be provided to improve the accuracy of the algorithm.
應用影像處理辨識香蕉葉片病變的軟體，開發出來的結果，其功能性、可用性、可靠性、性能、及可攜性都有很好的表現。該研究缺乏完整的報告，無法了解使用的方法是否有經過統計的分析判別。如果能夠把建議事項再完成，系統更能夠發揮功能。
Applying image processing to identify banana leaf lesions, the developed software has excellent functionality, usability, reliability, performance, and portability. The study lacked complete reporting to know whether the methods used were statistically analysed. If the suggested items can be completed again, the system will be more able to function.
PETEX: A Pet Transportation Management System with Courier Rider Allocation using Rule-based Approach
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The project aims to enable pet owners to avail goods and services safely and conveniently from pet shops and delivery or courier services. Users will be responsible for legal documents of their pets just by being in their own dwellings. The tracking module will track and record the exact area of the customer.
委員2
The students were able to develop an application that would manage the pet transportation services that includes the unique algorithm
“Rule-based algorithm”. The Rule-Based algorithm in the system is an intelligent way for the system to find and allocate a rider while following the given set of standards that would find the rider and provide a faster service.
The group must be able to show or justify the needs for this application.
委員3
The system can provide decision support mechanism to be integrated in platform.
委員4
海報沒有把研究的重點表達清楚，簡報可以講得更清楚。利用軟體開發的技巧完成的研究非常好，所得的結果也令人滿意，如果能夠把建議事項再完成，系統更能夠發揮功能。
The poster did not convey the main points of the study clearly, the presentation could have made it clearer. The research done using the skills of software development is very good and the results obtained are satisfactory. If the recommendations can be followed up, the system will be more functional.
委員5
Such an innovative idea could turn around the pet distribution market. However, I am not that sure if there is really a need for this application or how would the market welcome such processes. I would still believe that most would be pet owners would still be going through the more conventional way of looking for their desired pets. However, in places where limitations and restrictions are held due to weather or its geographic conditions, this proposal could be highly welcomed.
Sustainable design analysis: Identifying key factors in plastic to metal straw transition in Metro Manila via discrete choice modelling
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
Very relevant and significant topic. Would appreciate more analysis of data and results in paper to add credibility to the application. Nevertheless, wonderful research.
委員2
Early identification of Leukemia through ML and image processing are the functions of this product presented. The use of ML is an area that can definitely be explored in this field since image processing already exists. However, there is still much to be learned and it is suggested that the group further investigate studies and devices abroad for comparison. The specific SDG is not clear, but it may be related to SDG 3. Group should clarify.
委員3
The puzzles should not be deterministic, it must provide replayeability to players.
委員4
該計劃利用影像處理與計算機視覺技巧，並且利用物件導向程式設計，針對血液細胞檢測分辨白血病的精確度很高，是一個可行的方法。若能依醫生、專家們所提的意見進行改善，則系統更能夠發揮功能。
The project uses image processing and computer vision techniques, and uses object-oriented programming to detect leukemia with high accuracy for blood cell detection, which is a feasible method. If it can be improved according to the opinions of doctors and experts, the system will be able to function better.
Automatic Single-Axis Solar Tracking Concentrated Photovoltaic System with an Aluminum Alloy Heat Sink
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The team successfully controlled the temperature of the solar panel using heat sinks installed at the back of the solar panel and a single-axis solar tracker, which increases the overall efficiency of the PV system. This PV system was installed in Binangonan Rizal, a town in the Philippines to provide a clean alternative source to power their lighting system and charging stations since they experience frequent power interruptions. The team may explore a dual-axis solar tracker and an optimal number of heat sinks to increase further the overall efficiency.
该团队使用安装在太阳能电池板背面的散热器和单轴太阳能跟踪器成功地控制了太阳能电池板的温度，从而提高了光伏系统的整体效率。该光伏系统安装在菲律宾的 Binangonan Rizal 镇，为他们的照明系统和充电站提供清洁的替代能源，因为他们经常遇到电力中断。该团队可能会探索双轴太阳能跟踪器和最佳数量的散热器，以进一步提高整体效率。
委員2
1. The group was able to design a prototype of an automatic single axis solar tracking concentrated photovoltaic system with an aluminum alloy sink. They were able to test it in three modes of operation.
2. The best thing is that they were able to donate this to a community barangay in Rizal Province providing electricity for charging station and emergency lighting purposes. This a good example student's projects who can contribute to the betterment of the society.
委員3
1.thermocouple 位置沒有顯示出？
2.因為solar panel with reflectors被固定，solar tracking是以哪一個為計算標的？
3.為何要用Aluminum Reflectors？不是比較貴。
4.page 14-為什麼7:00-11:30 solar panel with reflectors and solar tracking 溫度高於 conventional溫度，請問是3次實驗的平均值嗎? 沒有error bar？
5. page 14-為什麼7:00-9:00 proposed prototype溫度會較高，請問是3次實驗的平均值嗎? 沒有error bar？不是說proposed prototype溫度會較低。
6.沒有顯示12個散熱器。
7.經過鍊條傳動，傳動效率會再降低許多，多產的電夠補充嗎？應該有更好的方式。
8. solar tracking系統的電是用何處的電？應用太陽光電所產生的電，請問計算效率時有扣掉solar tracking系統所耗的電嗎？
9. solar panel with reflectors：反射片大小及角度有計算過嗎？
委員4
追蹤太陽及降低太陽能板的背面溫度是很好的提升太陽能效率的方法，如果能夠在這兩方面做更多的實驗研究，應該是有幫助的。
Tracking the sun and reducing the temperature on the back of the solar panel are good ways to improve solar efficiency. It should be helpful to do more experimental research on these two aspects.
The incinerator project was already tested and turned over to a remote barangay where electricity is the main problem. Aside from solving the power problems of the community, the project had addressed also the issues on wastes and gender empowerment. The wastes are used for the incinerator and the community will tapped the women and youth of the village in the operation of the project. The main suggestion to this project is to promote the project through information and dissemination nationwide, so that there will be knowledge transfer to other villages that have the same problem on power and wastes.
委員2
1. The students were able to design and produce a prototype that Instead of burning the waste or dumping it in the landfills, it will
be processed in this prototype to lessen its environmental impact.
2. They were able to use an air filter bags and crushed mussels which lessen the air pollution produced during the incineration process
of the waste as it builds up heat. The build-up heat would be absorbed by the thermoelectric converter, convert heat to electricity, and stored in a battery.
3. This project was used in three (3) barangays in the Municipality of San Andres, Catanduanes, namely Brgy. Bislig, Brgy. Cabcab, and Brgy. Codon. This is a good example of direct implementation of student's project in the community.
該研究的成果，可以提供城郊農村小型垃圾焚化發電設備，是一個優良的創意。如能依建議在污染防治上加強研究，可以得到更有效的廢棄物焚化減量的效果。
The results of this research can provide small-scale waste incineration power generation equipment in suburban countryside, which is an excellent idea. If the research on pollution prevention and control can be strengthened as suggested, more effective waste incineration reduction effect can be obtained.
CHARLIE: A Digital Awareness Campaign with Reporting System on Online Sexual Harassment for UNFPA Philippines
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
this project consist of hybrid animation series, digital campaign, and the website, will help young generations to educate and raise awareness to online sexual harassment.
委員2
Charlie means Change in Relative to One’s Initiative. Charlie’s Solution to problem regarding the issue on online sexual harassment. The UNFPA Philippines and the proponents aimed to develop an online awareness campaign utilizing Information Technology and Digital Arts output to help educate social media users on the issue and impart knowledge to understand online sexual harassment effectively and encourage reporting. Recommend further testing to ensure service efficiency.
委員3
The documents and discussion should be validated by experts.
Personalization of Prosthetics for Amputated People Using 3D Modeling
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The system will help improve the self-esteem of the amputated individuals by having personalized design prosthetics done by using advanced 3D-modeling technology.
委員2
The technology merges 3D modeling and design with the utilization of 3D printing to produce customized prosthetics limbs and legs for amputees. 3D modeling and printing for prosthetics are already being done, however personalizing is part of how the prosthetics can be made. Recommending that the group test the viability of this product and how effective it can be to simply order customized prosthetics online. References can be made to existing online suppliers of prosthetics.
Isolation: An Interactive Animated Trilogy Short Film About Mental Health Awareness During The COVID-19 Pandemic
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The video needs little polishing but it shows the creators' abilities to make very good animation. It has presented the mental health concerns brought about by the pandemic, but it does not really provide any solution to it except self-motivation. It only shows the mental challenges faced by a few sectors of the society but the narrative is dragging, it does not offer new information and it fails to even get a call for action.
委員2
The study is very relevant and important as we face uncertainty in our lives.
The topic is in line with the direction of SDG 3. Expressive arts therapy is also an emerging form of psychotherapy, and the production of these videos is fine. Unfortunately, the film is not constructed based on a formal framework for art therapy, nor is there sufficient evidence to support the impact of the film. It is a pity that no concrete conclusions can be drawn.
Care For Paws: Healthcare and Identification System for Domesticated Animals with the Integration of Web and Mobile Application
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
Study and prototype are constructive with high potential of transformation into a community initiative.
委員2
1. The students were able to develop both web and mobile application that will allows individuals to identifyany missing animals within the information inputted in the NFC,displays the profiles of animals that currently resides in the animal shelter, and the ability for pet owners to track their animal’s health.
2. This project will help pet owners in taking care the health of their pets.
委員3
團隊試圖要為流浪動物，打造一個關懷網站，及透過 NFC 與手機 APP 互動可以追蹤寵物的系統。但介紹的網站是 2021 年 11 月上線，Care for Paws Shelter Sanctuary - CPSS Inc. 的官網(可自archive.org取得歷史資料)，NFC 部分如何記錄儲存資料、如何與資料庫連線顯示資料的系統架構均無，APP 也只有模擬的 UI。沒有實體的操作環境，卻可以得到極佳的使用者經驗評分，讓人著實懷疑評分的標的與本計畫是否一致。
委員4
整合網路與手機的應用，關懷寵物照顧計劃的立意很好，但是缺乏完整的製作報告，無法了解製作的過程與方法。
Integrating the application of the Internet and mobile phones, the idea of caring for the pet care plan is very good, but the lack of a complete production report makes it impossible to understand the production process and methods.
They were able to learn and apply how to use CNN in classifying skin diseases, furthermore mapping it to appropriate local skin care ingredient (generic) product to use. It is highly suggested that the project should be trained with additional skin disease datasets to further detect diseases not covered in the study.
委員2
The research contributes solution for health skin care that uses mobile technologies with the inclusion of applying image processing and some model design. The group were presented the main objective of their research and able to present demonstration capturing skin images with some validations. For recommendation a pattern must be provided for different kind of skin diseases that will most likely suggest some relevant solution to skin care. An expert and some more dermatologist needs to validate the data that was produced. Further explore different skin tone in detection and provide more graphical demonstration on health care tips. The researcher must be able to cite the image diagram that were presented and have more presentable conceptual frameworks that will easily define their projects.
The advantages: This technology is important for many people.
The advantage The disadvantages: For SDGs relation is weak. The idea has been world-wide know. Suggest to point out the differences from the other similar products'software and so on.
Prediction of Possible Leukemia in Microscopic Blood Cell Images: A Machine Learning and Image Processing Approach
優等 the Excellence Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The project is very promising. It can be implemented in rural areas where technology is not yet evident. Clinics may save a lot of money using the application. Mobile clinics will not need to worry about purchasing expensive hematology analyzers. Instead, they can direct their budget to reach communities as possible by hiring more medical personnel.
委員2
The students were able to provide an image processing approach to predict
possible leukemia using machine learning and algorithm. They were able to test and train the data and were able to quantify the number
of blast cells from microscopic blood cell images.
委員3
The study should also be validated by medical experts.
This project designs and implements an online proctored entrance examination system with degree program recommender for colleges and universities. The corresponding evaluations are also performed to present the functionality, usability, reliability, performance, and security of the proposed system. The system is well designed, and the effort into the software development is highly appreciated. The system will be very useful in the new normal. In addition, the data preserved in the system can be leveraged for further usage and analysis. Some minor suggestions are listed in the following:
1. Some diagrams can be used to depict the static and dynamic aspectts of the system (e.g., use case diagram, component diagram, and so on).
2. Pseudo code can be used when presenting the algorithm.
委員5
利用Scrum方法開發線上考試系統構想不錯，利用FURPS模型提出不同的問題評估系統品質與性能所得的結果都受到學生、教職員以及IT專家人士的認同。如果能將建議事項都實現，這系統就會很完善。
The idea of using the Scrum method to develop an online examination system is good. The results obtained by using the FURPS model to raise different questions to evaluate the quality and performance of the system are recognized by students, teaching staff and IT experts. If all the recommendations can be implemented, the system will be perfect.
Microprocessor-Based Interactive Mathematics Learning Tool Using Real - Time Computer Vision
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
Improvements could be done on how the data is acquired and presented, data is too simplistic, depth and further understanding could be acquired from the data set if only a more meaningful set of data was acquired. However, the study is worthy, furthering education technology is always a noble cause.
委員2
The study can help students to learn the beauty of Math.
委員3
作品為在Rasberry pi 利用語音指示和影像處理技術即時辨識手指數目作為簡單算術題的答案，和小孩互動，教導小孩學習算術。作者群呈現在rasberry pi建立影像app的能力。建議可嘗試加入其他和手勢可表達的概念，增加做絣的實用性。
委員4
This project develops a system to help children to learn mathematics efficiently. The developed system can display mathematic questions on screen, detect answers from children by gesture recognition, and finally output the result. The proposed system is designed and built by software and hardware components, and the corresponding evaluations are performed. It is a very complete system and it faciliates the goal of "quality education" in SDGs efficiently. Also, it is anticipated that children will like the system to learn.
Some minor suggestions are listed in the following for this great team.
1. The method to improve the precision can be analyzed and designed.
2. Audio can also be used as input for answer.
3. The method to recognize complex answers can be analyzed and designed.
委員5
能夠引起學童學習數學的興趣，提高學童思考能力及學習慾望的設計理念是很好的構想。
原型設計適合初學數學的小學生，如能夠加入更深級別的數學問題，將可以使系統更完善、更實用。
It is a good idea to arouse children's interest in learning mathematics and improve their thinking ability and learning desire.
The prototype design is suitable for elementary school students who are beginning to learn mathematics. If more advanced mathematics problems can be added, the system will be more complete and more practical.
oneBarangay: An e-Government System for Online Transaction Processing of Barangay Malanday Main Office through Web and Mobile Applications with Implementation of OCR Technologies
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
I am proud of this group for pulling this research off.
委員2
The service is an electronic platform for the local government which is aligned with the digitalization and digitization strategy to achieve the SDGs. This is a good way to streamline and make government services more accessible to citizens. Although eGovernment platforms are already being developed, the barangay level or the smallest government unit in the Philippines will have very good use for this product.
委員3
The E-government system provides flexibility and generic approach to be a start up project that can be adopted by different barangays.
委員4
The results of this project can be further presented to make a more practical explanation in terms of academics and practitioners for their achievement of the initial research objectives.
iNailed-IT: Web and Mobile Customer Management Information System
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The system shows innovative aspect in the field chosen. Very good system.
委員2
1. First, the service is not linked to any SDG. Second, while the mobile application is helpful, this is not a new idea because mobile applications for services have been in the market even prior to pandemic.
2. The group should revisit any possibility that their product can be linked to SDG and how it can be helpful to the community at large.
委員3
The study should also include new trends in technology.
委員4
The idea of this project is good and interesting. The team has also clearly outlined the objectives of their study. After a careful review on their materials, I think the project team members have illustrated good research outcomes of this project. This project may proffer good practical applications and potential contributions.
委員5
1.專案的背景中有清楚提到痛點與需求，目的也有相互呼應，SDGs連結較少，其中在背景裡提及Employee Availability可透過系統解決，符合SDGs中的目標8“Decent Work and Economic Growth”。
2.系統原理與方法，這組找了五個不同使用的角度來評分較為客觀（如：顧客、管理者、IT技術人員等），但缺少系統架構描述。
3.結果有清楚描述對顧客與店家的實用性，其中nail design module的功能具有創新性。
4.討論僅說明系統未來可增加的功能而已。
Cassius: A Sandbox-Based Stealth Game Set in The Victorian Era with Community Platform System
不推薦 Not recommended
FEUT-F04
GIGL: VR Website Implementing Spatial Audio in Streaming Virtual Concerts
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The group has an exemptional performance and teamwork. The project is innovative.
委員2
The VR website specifically for streaming concerts is interesting and can be beneficial for both consumers and artists. However, there is no clear link to the SDGs that can be found in the presentation. Group can revisit their product and their overarching purpose aligned with perhaps promoting inclusive and sustainable economic growth.
委員3
Include payment methodology and provide comprehensive report generations.
委員4
1.專案的背景中有提到菲律賓歌手在疫情間生計上的痛點，符合SDGs中的目標8“Decent Work and Economic Growth”。
2.系統原理與方法，這組找了三個不同使用的角度來評分較為客觀（如：歌手、觀眾、IT技術人員等）。
3.有清楚說明系統架構，包含使用什麼模組、程式語言，並用demo展示系統成果。
4.沒有提到討論與結論。
委員5
The subject matter is innovative and the purpose of the study was complete and clear. Furthermore, the related research outcome of this projects also has relevant bright spots that can have excellent practical contributions and potential applications in the near future.
The White House: A 3D First-Person Horror Puzzle Game
不推薦 Not recommended
FEUT-F06
Artistik: Software Application and System Development for Art Trade and Experience
佳作 the Honorable Mention Award
評審委員評語
委員1
The research paper is an innovative way of helping artists sell their work.
委員2
The motivation in supporting the SDGs is not clear. Artistick is a web and mobile application that combines social media, ecommerce, and auction system. The innovation presented is the one platform for three functions and this supports local business. Suggest the group to revisit their study to make clear its contribution in achieving any of the UN SDGs.
委員3
The system should provide better configuration and flexibility in terms of the changing needs of users and clients.
委員4
The subject matter is innovative and the purpose of the study was complete and clear. Furthermore, the related research outcome of this project also has relevant bright spots that can have excellent practical contributions and potential applications in the near future.
